Asia WWC APAC Desk

Why the South China Sea Code of Conduct is difficult to finish

Why the South China Sea Code of Conduct is difficult to finish

The long-running negotiations are not simply about agreeing to a general promise to keep the peace. The parties must decide what areas the proposed rules will cover, what legal status the agreement will have and how it will build on an existing regional declaration.

Those questions were identified by the Philippine government as key subjects in the negotiations during its 2026 ASEAN chairship.

The first issue is geographical scope. A code needs a defined area of application if governments are to know where its provisions would operate. The Philippines has also stressed that the agreement must respect the rights and interests of third parties.

The second issue is legal nature. The Philippines has advocated an effective, substantive and legally binding agreement. Whether the final text will meet that standard is a central question for the negotiations.

The third issue is the relationship between the proposed code and the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea. The declaration already provides principles for restraint, peaceful dispute resolution and cooperation. The proposed code is expected to build on that foundation with more detailed rules for conduct at sea.

These distinctions explain why progress on draft language does not automatically mean that the agreement is ready for adoption. Negotiators must still settle the provisions that determine how the code will work in practice.

The legal framework also matters. The Philippines has consistently called for the proposed agreement to be consistent with the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. That requirement is significant because the code is intended to guide conduct at sea, not replace the legal framework governing maritime rights and obligations.

Ultimately, the value of the agreement will depend on more than its completion. Its geographical coverage, legal status and practical provisions will determine whether it can help manage tensions and improve predictability in the South China Sea.

Get our stories first on Google

More in Asia

See all in Asia