Philippines WWC APAC Desk

Sara Duterte’s Defence Witnesses Face a Bigger Test – Can They Explain the ₱817.87-Million Allegation?

Sara Duterte’s Defence Witnesses Face a Bigger Test – Can They Explain the ₱817.87-Million Allegation?

The defence team of Vice President Sara Duterte has faced growing scrutiny over its witness presentation in the Senate impeachment trial, where the remaining charge centres on allegations of unexplained wealth and incomplete financial disclosures. By Nov. 13, House prosecutors were publicly claiming that 18 of the 24 witnesses originally scheduled by the defence had been dropped or dispensed with.

The development has sharpened the central question in the case: can the defence directly address the financial evidence behind the prosecution’s ₱817.87-million estimate, or will the trial turn on narrower disputes over individual transactions and documents?

The amount is not an established finding of illegally acquired wealth. It is the estimate presented by prosecution forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera, covering alleged undeclared assets and unexplained wealth involving Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, from 2022 to 2025. Duterte denies wrongdoing, and her defence disputes the prosecution’s allegations. House of Representatives Philippines+2

The witness count has become part of the courtroom dispute

The defence entered the presentation phase with 24 prospective witnesses, a lineup that included bank officials, corporate representatives and other individuals expected to address matters raised by the prosecution.

But the number who would actually testify became a point of contention during the first week of the defence presentation.

In a Nov. 13 statement, House lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro said 18 of the 24 scheduled witnesses had been dropped or dispensed with. That figure reflects the prosecution’s public account of the proceedings, not a judicial finding that the defence had failed to answer the allegations.

The distinction matters. A witness may be dispensed with because the parties agree on a fact, because the testimony is no longer considered necessary, or because the defence changes its presentation strategy. The decision to call fewer witnesses does not, by itself, establish that the prosecution’s allegations are true.

The relevant question is what evidence the defence ultimately presents and whether it addresses the disputed financial records.

Why the ₱817.87-million figure remains central

Cabrera’s estimate is one of the most consequential pieces of the prosecution’s case.

The House prosecution said the forensic accounting examination drew on bank records, income tax returns, insurance documents, corporate filings and Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth, commonly known as SALNs.

The prosecution also disclosed that Cabrera discussed a higher estimate of as much as ₱1.5 billion under less conservative assumptions. That higher figure should not be confused with the principal estimate of ₱817.87 million.

Neither figure should be reported as a final determination of unlawful wealth. The Senate impeachment court must assess the underlying records, the expert’s methodology and the defence’s explanations before deciding whether the remaining charge has been proven. House of Representatives Philippines+1

Small transactions and major financial questions

Some of the defence testimony has drawn attention to individual purchases and expenses.

In its Nov. 12 statement, the House prosecution discussed testimony concerning a restaurant bill in Tokyo amounting to ₱205,007.29 and a Nike purchase in Kuala Lumpur worth ₱256,882.50. The prosecution argued that these transactions did not resolve the much larger financial questions raised by Cabrera’s report.

That is the prosecution’s assessment, not the Senate’s final conclusion.

Individual transactions may be relevant if they help establish who paid, who benefited, whether the transaction was properly documented and how it should be treated in the financial records. But their significance depends on the evidence and the specific issue being examined.

The defence is entitled to explain the transactions and challenge the prosecution’s interpretation. The prosecution, in turn, may test those explanations through cross-examination.

The dispute is therefore not simply about whether a purchase was made. It is about what the transaction proves, how it fits into the larger financial picture and whether it has any bearing on the remaining impeachment charge. House of Representatives Philippines+1

GenCorp testimony adds another layer to the SALN issue

The financial questions also include Duterte’s reported receipts from GenCorp Industries Inc.

In his Nov. 17 statement, Senator Panfilo Lacson discussed the testimony of GenCorp in-house counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay. As recounted in Lacson’s statement, Punay said Duterte received ₱2.14 million from GenCorp between 2022 and 2025 as a return of capital from an earlier investment connected to a Jollibee branch in Davao City.

Punay also said Duterte did not hold GenCorp shares or a corporate position during that period.

The explanation raises questions about how the original investment, its transfer and the subsequent payments should be documented and reflected in the relevant financial disclosures. But the payment’s legal significance cannot be determined from the amount alone.

WWC has already examined the issue in its report on the ₱2.14-million GenCorp payments and the defence witness’s testimony. That report should be updated with the latest developments rather than duplicated. PING LACSON+1

What the law requires — and what the Senate must decide

The legal question is broader than whether a particular bank account or business interest appears in a document.

Article XI, Section 17 of the 1987 Constitution requires public officers and employees to submit a declaration under oath of their assets, liabilities and net worth upon assuming office and as often as required by law.

Section 8 of Republic Act No. 6713 specifies the information that must be disclosed, including real and personal property, investments, cash, stocks, bonds, liabilities, business interests and financial connections.

These requirements provide the legal framework for examining the accuracy and completeness of public officials’ financial declarations. They do not mean that every discrepancy automatically establishes an impeachable offence.

Under Article XI, Section 3 of the Constitution, the Senate has the sole power to try and decide impeachment cases. Conviction requires the concurrence of two-thirds of all members of the Senate.

The senator-judges must therefore evaluate the evidence presented by both parties, not simply accept the prosecution’s interpretation or the defence’s explanations without examination. Official Gazette+1

What happens next

The Senate impeachment court’s scheduled Nov. 19 and 20 sessions will provide further opportunities for the defence to present evidence, subject to the court’s proceedings and rulings.

The most important measure of the defence presentation will not be the number of witnesses who take the stand. It will be whether the testimony and documents address the specific financial issues raised by the prosecution.

For the prosecution, the challenge is to establish that its calculations and documentary evidence support the remaining impeachment charge. For the defence, it is to demonstrate why those calculations, interpretations or conclusions should not be accepted.

The ₱817.87-million figure may dominate public discussion, but the Senate’s decision must rest on the evidence and the constitutional standard for conviction. Until the impeachment court reaches a judgment, the allegations remain contested.

Editorial note: The Nov. 13 witness count is attributed to the House prosecution’s public statement. The complete official hearing transcript and a court-certified accounting of every witness withdrawn or dispensed with were not independently verified.

Get our stories first on Google

More in Philippines

See all in Philippines