Senator-judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson has challenged the explanation that Vice President Sara Duterte’s inclusion of GenCorp Industries Inc. in her Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN) was simply an honest mistake.
In a statement published on Nov. 17, Lacson described an “honest mistake” as something that could have two very different meanings: an unintended error that reveals information, or a genuine misunderstanding of the facts. He said only the person responsible could ultimately explain which interpretation applied.
His remarks followed former chief presidential legal counsel Salvador Panelo’s assertion that Duterte had made an honest mistake in declaring GenCorp as a business interest.
The dispute comes after GenCorp in-house counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay testified during the impeachment proceedings about Duterte’s financial connection to a Jollibee branch in Davao City. Lacson’s statement referred to the witness’s explanation that Duterte received ₱2.14 million from GenCorp between 2022 and 2025, described as a return of capital from an earlier investment.
The central issue is not resolved simply by calling the SALN entry an error. The nature of the original investment, the financial arrangement, the payments and the disclosure requirements must all be considered alongside the relevant records.
The legal framework makes financial disclosure a public accountability requirement. Section 17, Article XI of the 1987 Constitution requires public officers to submit declarations of assets, liabilities and net worth. Section 8 of Republic Act No. 6713 also requires covered officials to disclose assets, liabilities, financial interests and business connections.
That does not mean an inaccurate declaration automatically establishes an impeachable offence. The Senate impeachment court must assess the evidence, the circumstances surrounding the declaration and the applicable constitutional provisions before reaching a conclusion.
For readers following the case, the distinction is important: a defence based on an honest mistake concerns the circumstances and intent behind a declaration, while the impeachment proceedings require the senator-judges to evaluate the evidence and determine whether the remaining charge has been established.
The question now is whether the explanation can be supported by the underlying financial and corporate records.
Primary records checked: Lacson’s Nov. 17 statement, 1987 Constitution and Republic Act No. 6713.
