BONTOC, Mountain Province — A journey from Isabela to Benguet ended in tragedy after an Elf truck plunged as much as 100 meters down a steep ravine in Bontoc, killing six people—including an infant—and injuring 17 others.
The crash happened at about 12:40 p.m. on Tuesday, September 15, along the Talubin-Barlig Road in Sitio Jakap, Barangay Talubin, according to local emergency responders and police reports. The vehicle was traveling from Isabela toward Bakun, Benguet, via the Paracelis route when it went off the mountain road.
Six victims were confirmed dead: five adults and an infant. Seventeen others survived with injuries, making the crash one of the deadliest road accidents reported in Mountain Province this year.
But more than a day after the tragedy, one of the most important questions remains unanswered:
Why did the truck leave the road in the first place?
The truck fell between 50 and 100 meters
Emergency officials said the vehicle plunged roughly 50 to 100 meters down the mountainside.
That range reflects differing estimates from rescuers and police arriving at the steep crash site. The terrain complicated both access to the wreck and the evacuation of survivors.
Initial reports said rescue operations were further hampered by rugged terrain and weak or nonexistent communications signals in the area.
Teams from Bontoc and nearby local governments were mobilized as authorities tried to determine how many people had been on the truck and whether anyone remained down the ravine.
The first hours produced changing casualty figures as rescuers reached more victims.
That is why some early news alerts reported only seven people rescued while around 20 were still believed missing. Those numbers were later overtaken as the operation progressed.
Six dead, including an infant
By late Tuesday afternoon, responders had confirmed six fatalities—five adults and one infant.
Local reporting identified one adult fatality as Theresa Walitan. Reports differed over the infant’s exact age and name, so those details should be treated cautiously until authorities issue a definitive public casualty list.
Bombo Radyo, citing Bontoc police chief Maj. Robert Sagandoy, reported that the fatalities included four adult women, one adult man and an infant. Police were continuing to coordinate with the victims’ families following the crash.
The loss of an infant has made the tragedy especially painful for the families involved, but officials have asked that identifying information be handled carefully while relatives are being notified.
Seventeen people were injured—but not all remained hospitalized
The figure of 17 injured can appear inconsistent with some reports saying only 15 were hurt.
The explanation is straightforward.
Seventeen survivors required medical treatment, but two were treated and later discharged, leaving 15 admitted or receiving further hospital care.
Daily Tribune reported that the injured were initially taken to Bontoc General Hospital, with two young patients treated as outpatients and released. One more seriously injured passenger was transferred to Luis Hora Regional Memorial Hospital for additional treatment.
Bombo Radyo likewise reported that 16 people were brought to Bontoc General Hospital for treatment and assessment, while another was sent to Luis Hora Regional Memorial Hospital.
So the most accurate current wording is:
Six dead. Seventeen injured in total. Fifteen remained hospitalized after two were discharged.
Was the truck carrying 23 people—or 27?
This is another detail where early reports conflict.
Several initial reports from the Bontoc Emergency Operations Center and MDRRMO said the Elf truck was carrying around 27 passengers. Daily Tribune, Inquirer and other outlets carried that estimate during the rescue operation.
Later police-based reporting referred to 23 occupants.
That figure matches the final casualty accounting exactly:
6 fatalities + 17 injured = 23 people.
Bombo Radyo reported that rescuers had recovered or accounted for all 23 occupants.
The Philippine Star also reported a 23-person passenger count based on Mountain Province police, though the photo caption accompanying the same story still referred to about 27 passengers—showing how quickly information changed during the rescue operation.
Until authorities release a final incident report, the safest formulation is that early responders estimated roughly 27 occupants, while later confirmed casualty figures account for 23 people.
The group was traveling from Isabela to Bakun
Multiple reports agree that the truck had come from Isabela and was traveling toward Bakun, Benguet, using the route through Paracelis and Bontoc.
The crash occurred as the vehicle traveled along the Talubin-Barlig Road through the mountainous Cordillera terrain.
Officials in Bakun and relatives of the victims later coordinated with Bontoc’s emergency operations center to assist survivors and arrange for the remains of those killed to be brought home.
Some local reports indicated that a number of the passengers may have been related to one another, but authorities had not publicly established a complete relationship among all the people aboard.
Did the driver lose control?
Some reports say the vehicle lost control and scraped or struck the roadside before plunging down the ravine.
Pilipino Star Ngayon and Pang-Masa carried that version based on preliminary reports.
But that is not the same as an official determination of cause.
Daily Tribune’s later account said authorities were still investigating why the vehicle fell from the road, and Bontoc police likewise said the investigation remained ongoing.
There was no confirmed public finding, as of September 16, establishing brake failure, speeding, mechanical failure, driver error, road conditions or weather as the definitive cause.
That distinction matters in accident reporting.
A vehicle losing control describes what may have happened immediately before it left the roadway.
It does not necessarily explain why control was lost.
Rescue teams faced a difficult mountain environment
The location created problems almost immediately.
The vehicle had fallen far below the roadway, and emergency personnel had to operate on steep ground while communications coverage was limited.
Cordillera police spokesperson Lt. Col. Genevieve Revocal said the terrain and lack of signal complicated operations.
The Bontoc local government and emergency teams from surrounding communities responded to help recover victims and move the injured toward medical facilities.
Initial reports were therefore necessarily incomplete.
At one stage, only seven survivors had been reached and around 20 people were still believed unaccounted for.
By later Tuesday, responders had established the far more complete toll of six deaths and 17 injuries.
Bontoc community held a traditional ritual after the crash
On Wednesday, Bontoc elders and community leaders held a traditional cleansing ritual at the municipal “ato,” or traditional council house, following the fatal accident.
Daily Tribune reported that the ceremony took place as the community mourned the six deaths.
The ritual reflects the continuing role of indigenous Bontoc customs during moments of communal loss.
It does not replace the official investigation, which remains the responsibility of police and other authorities.
The final cause could determine what comes next
For investigators, the central unanswered questions now concern the vehicle and the moments immediately before it left the Talubin-Barlig Road.
Authorities will need to establish whether the truck experienced a mechanical problem, whether road or weather conditions contributed, whether driver actions played a role, and how many passengers were officially aboard.
Those issues have not yet been resolved publicly.
The difference between the early estimate of 27 passengers and the later accounting of 23 is also likely to be clarified in the formal investigation.
For families, however, the most immediate facts are already painfully clear.
A truck carrying passengers homeward across the Cordillera left the road shortly after midday.
It fell tens of meters down a ravine.
Seventeen people survived.
Six did not.
And while the rescue operation has largely answered who was found, investigators still have to answer the question at the center of the tragedy: what caused the truck to plunge off the mountain road?
Leave a Reply